Editor: G A Starr
April 1730 saw the publication of Christianity as Old as the Creation, a work which came to be known as ‘the Deists’ Bible’. Barely a month later, an anonymous pamphlet appeared in response. Christianity Not as Old as the Creation challenged not simply the author of the volume, Matthew Tindal, but the religious philosophy of Deism in general.
Using A New Family Instructor (1727) for comparative analysis, Starr argues that there is enough convincing internal evidence – and a concurrent absence of any conflicting external evidence – for a ‘probable’ attribution to Daniel Defoe.
This is the first time Christianity Not as Old as the Creation has appeared in a scholarly edition. Starr’s attribution is not only a significant contribution to Defoe scholarship, but in making it he simultaneously provides an excellent ‘how to’ guide for scholars wishing to add other non-attributed works to the Defoe canon.